Falsely Convicted Man Describes Long Road to Exoneration

Author: Kevin Allen

Keith Cooper Keith Cooper speaks to Notre Dame Law School students on April 12 in the Eck Hall of Law.

The series of events that swept Keith Cooper into the criminal-justice system – and sent him to prison for a crime he didn’t commit – is so nightmarish that it sounds like something out of a screenplay or a novel.

But, unfortunately, Cooper’s story happened in real life.

In 1997, Cooper went from a man with two jobs and no criminal record to a convicted felon – sentenced to serve 40 years in prison for an armed robbery at an apartment complex in Elkhart, Ind.

“It was like my life was over,” he said. “I had a wife and three children. I told my wife at the time, ‘Get on with your life. Don’t wait on me.’”

Cooper and his attorney, Elliot Slosar of the Chicago-based civil-rights law firm Loevy & Loevy, spoke last week at Notre Dame Law School. Cooper talked about the combination of bad luck and official misconduct that led to his arrest and conviction, and Slosar described the decades-long process that finally led to Cooper clearing his name.

“I was at a breaking point. I was ready to give up,” Cooper said of his mindset before he met Slosar.

Elliot Slosar Chicago-based attorney Elliot Slosar talks about his work to help Keith Cooper clear his name after a wrongful felony conviction.

Cooper was completely innocent of the robbery, but he happened to be a tall, skinny black man – like the robbery suspect. The witnesses who testified against him would later recant their stories, and DNA from a hat left at the robbery scene would point to a different man as the perpetrator.

That new information in Cooper’s case led to him being released from prison in 2006.

“That was one of the happiest moments of my life – to be told, ‘Keith, you’re back among the living,’” he said.

But – while Cooper was relieved to be free after nine years in prison – he still carried the burden of the felony conviction, which remained on his record and hurt his opportunities for employment.

In 2014, the Indiana Parole Board recommended that then-Gov. Mike Pence pardon Cooper. Even the attorney who prosecuted Cooper wrote a letter urging Pence to grant the pardon.

Nevertheless, Pence declined.

It wasn’t until February, when Pence’s successor, Gov. Eric Holcomb, was in office that Cooper was pardoned of the robbery conviction.

Slosar was an investigator at Loevy & Loevy and still a student at DePaul University College of Law while working on Cooper’s case and petitioning for his pardon. Slosar’s efforts were part of the Exoneration Project at the University of Chicago Law School.

“There are many people out there who would love your help – even before you’re admitted (to the bar),” Slosar said.

“I would urge you, no matter what type of law you practice, to engage in pro-bono work,” he said. “There are a number of wrongfully convicted people in America and elsewhere.”

Standing ovation Notre Dame Law School students give Keith Cooper and Elliot Slosar a standing ovation on April 12 in the Eck Hall of Law.

Jimmy Gurulé, a professor of law at Notre Dame Law School, called Cooper’s case a “travesty of justice.”

Gurulé encouraged students to think about how such a case could happen – despite all of the protections the U.S. Constitution provides for defendants – and how it can be prevented from happening again.

“You might think when I’m talking about this case that I’m talking about the criminal-justice system of some foreign country – a criminal-justice system of a country that doesn’t have a developed system of justice based on the rule of law, based on the Constitution,” Gurulé said. “But that’s not the case. We’re talking about our criminal justice system, the American criminal-justice system – a justice system that broke down.”

The Innocence Project Club at Notre Dame Law School sponsored the event.